i would a confirm of this: with polyphase structure is possible only design a filter bank with a INTEGER oversampling ratio? For non-integer i've seen the weighted overlap-add metod, is right?
thanks S.
Add a comment
|
1 Answer
$\begingroup$
$\endgroup$
6
If you have a 1D uniform $M$-channel multirate filter bank (FB), and $N$ is the decimation ($M \ge N$), rational oversampling ratios ($M/N$) are indeed possible (see Fig. 2), or from Figure 1 in Optimization of Synthesis Oversampled Complex Filter Banks, J. Gautier et al., IEEE Trans. Signal Processing, 2009 (doi), which provides optimized synthesis FB with any ratio (like $7/4$).
More precisely: for an analysis filter bank, you can choose any decimation you want. But you may loose information, and the invertibility of the analysis/synthesis system. In a lot of practical applications (for instance in speech processing), integer oversampling ratios are quite common, by choosing $N = M/k$, for instance $k=M/2$ or $k=M/4$. Such choices make the computations and some calculations much simpler: for instance, an inverse synthesis filter bank may take a closed form, related to the analysis window for DFT FBs.
However with redundancy, there are an infinity of inverses, and polyphase formulations help finding synthesis FBs.
A set of useful books (to me):
- Subband compression of images: principles and examples, T. Ramstad et al., 1995
- Wavelets and Subband Coding, M. Vetterli et al., 1995
- Wavelets and filte banks, G. Strang et al., 1996
answered Jan 5, 2016 at 22:16
-
$\begingroup$ Thanks! It's awesome paper! I don't Know why the book of Crochiere "Multirate Digital Signal Processing" says only integer oversampling ratio.. $\endgroup$– Ste3191Commented Jan 5, 2016 at 23:09
-
$\begingroup$ 1st edition, page 325 where talks about comparision between polyphase and wola. $\endgroup$– Ste3191Commented Jan 6, 2016 at 10:22
-
$\begingroup$ I understand the chapter as "In this section [...] the polyphase structure is limited primarily to the critically sampled case where $M = K$ or to cases when $MI = K$, where $I$ is an integer". Sooner, they say that "This realization is most easily seen for the case of critically sampled filter banks where $M = K$. Designs for other choices of $M$ (or $K$) are not as straightforward as the critically sampled case". Primarily is important here. It does not mean it is impossible $\endgroup$ Commented Jan 6, 2016 at 19:35
-
$\begingroup$ Ok i didn't understand well. Thanks. I have another doubt .(, having M channels, N decimation factor and polyphase structure. In all documents, the analysis polyphase matrix is MxN. But Why? If the prototype filter H0 has length L, the matrix should have M x L/M, or not? Namely, for me each row of this matrix represents one polyphase component of length L/M. Where do i wrong? $\endgroup$– Ste3191Commented Jan 6, 2016 at 21:04
-
$\begingroup$ Polyphase behave like a subsampling of filter coefficients by $N$. So you have the subsequences $0, N, 2N...$, $1, N+1, 2N+1...$ up to $N-1,2N-1, ...$, hence $(N-1)-0+1$ polyphase component per filter. The polyphase size does not depend on the filter size, which is one of its main advantages. $\endgroup$ Commented Jan 6, 2016 at 21:30