Skip to main content
Notice removed Reward existing answer by Rojo
Bounty Ended with Bryan's answer chosen by Rojo
edited tags
Link
learnvst
  • 1.5k
  • 2
  • 18
  • 25
Notice added Reward existing answer by Rojo
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Rojo
typos
Source Link
Spacey
  • 9.9k
  • 9
  • 44
  • 79

Welch's method has been my go-to algorithm for computing power spectral density (PSD) of evenly-sampled timeseries. I noticed that there are many other methods for computing PSD. For example, in Matlab I see:

  • PSD using BurbBurg method
  • PSD using covariance method
  • PSD using periodogram
  • PSD using modified covariance method
  • PSD using multitaper method (MTM)
  • PSD using Welch's method
  • PSD using Yule-Walker AR method
  • Spectrogram using short-time Fourier transform
  • Spectral estimation

What are the advantages of these various methods? As a practical question, when would I want to use something other than Welch's method?

Welch's method has been my go-to algorithm for computing power spectral density (PSD) of evenly-sampled timeseries. I noticed that there are many other methods for computing PSD. For example, in Matlab I see:

  • PSD using Burb method
  • PSD using covariance method
  • PSD using periodogram
  • PSD using modified covariance method
  • PSD using multitaper method (MTM)
  • PSD using Welch's method
  • PSD using Yule-Walker AR method
  • Spectrogram using short-time Fourier transform
  • Spectral estimation

What are the advantages of these various methods? As a practical question, when would I want to use something other than Welch's method?

Welch's method has been my go-to algorithm for computing power spectral density (PSD) of evenly-sampled timeseries. I noticed that there are many other methods for computing PSD. For example, in Matlab I see:

  • PSD using Burg method
  • PSD using covariance method
  • PSD using periodogram
  • PSD using modified covariance method
  • PSD using multitaper method (MTM)
  • PSD using Welch's method
  • PSD using Yule-Walker AR method
  • Spectrogram using short-time Fourier transform
  • Spectral estimation

What are the advantages of these various methods? As a practical question, when would I want to use something other than Welch's method?

Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackSignals/status/192570170055729153
Source Link
nibot
  • 3.8k
  • 5
  • 30
  • 40

Why so many methods of computing PSD?

Welch's method has been my go-to algorithm for computing power spectral density (PSD) of evenly-sampled timeseries. I noticed that there are many other methods for computing PSD. For example, in Matlab I see:

  • PSD using Burb method
  • PSD using covariance method
  • PSD using periodogram
  • PSD using modified covariance method
  • PSD using multitaper method (MTM)
  • PSD using Welch's method
  • PSD using Yule-Walker AR method
  • Spectrogram using short-time Fourier transform
  • Spectral estimation

What are the advantages of these various methods? As a practical question, when would I want to use something other than Welch's method?