0
$\begingroup$

A PAM signal is transmitted with bit 1 represented by $\pm A$ and bit 0 by 0 for a duration of T. They asked me to get the probability of error of the signaling, I found that $P_{e}=\frac 32*Q(\frac{A}{\sigma})$. But the result given is: $P_{e}=Q(\frac{3A}{2\sigma})+2Q(\frac{A}{2\sigma})$

Did I make a mistake when calculating the probability of error for bit 1?

I took the Threshold of decision is $\pm \frac A2$ then

$P_{e}(bit 1)=\frac 14 *(Q(\frac{-A/2+A}{\sigma})+1-Q(\frac{A/2-A}{\sigma}))$

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

1
$\begingroup$

Both your calculation and your "book"'s answer are incorrect.

When a $1$ is transmitted (whether as $+A$ or $-A$, it doesn't matter), the receiver decision is incorrect if and only if the demodulator output is in the interval $\left[-\frac A2, +\frac A2\right]$. Hence, $$P_{e,1} = Q\left(\frac{A}{2\sigma}\right) - Q\left(\frac{3A}{2\sigma}\right).$$ When a $0$ is transmitted, the receiver decision is incorrect if and only if the demodulator output is not in the interval $\left[-\frac A2, +\frac A2\right]$. Hence, $$P_{e,0} = 2Q\left(\frac{A}{2\sigma}\right).$$ Assuming $0$ and $1$ are equally likely to be transmitted, the average error probability is $$P_e = \frac 32 Q\left(\frac{A}{2\sigma}\right) - \frac 12 Q\left(\frac{3A}{2\sigma}\right).$$ If the transmitter were not choosing randomly between $\pm A$ when transmitting a $1$, the threshold would be $\frac A2$ ($-\frac A2$ for negative thinkers) and a smaller error probability $Q\left(\frac{A}{2\sigma}\right)$ would be achieved.

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ yes now I Got it, another question please for the signal $\pm A$ if we use a correlator do we use as reference signal only A or we separate for A we use A and for -A we use -A? because on the first case if we use only A as a reference signal we got $z(T) =\pm A^2 T $ and if we separate we got $z(T) =\ A^2 T $ only $\endgroup$
    – Mouh Kramo
    Commented Aug 19 at 21:38
  • $\begingroup$ Use a single filter/correlator. The filter output is a Gaussian random variable that has mean $\pm A$ or $0$ according as a $1$ or a $0$ was transmitted, and variance $\sigma^2$. . If the output is in $\left[\frac A2, +\frac A2\right]$, declare that a $0$ was transmitted; else declare that a $1$ was transmitted. $\endgroup$ Commented Aug 20 at 2:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.