1
$\begingroup$

By my understanding, a transform T is homogeneous if T[0] = 0.

Then to prove that a linear transformation is homogeneous we say that:

T[ax(n1, n2) + bx(n1, n2)] = aT[x(n1, n2)] + bT[x(n1, n2)]

What I want to know is the difference between the following two proofs and which one is "more correct" or is there perhaps a even better answer?

let x(n1, n2) = 0

then we know that,

ax(n1,n2)- ax(n1,n2) = 0, T[ax(n1, n2) + ax(n1, n2)] = aT[x(n1, n2)] + aT[x(n1, n2)] = 0

VS

Simply showing that both sides are equal to 0 if x(n1, n2) = 0 through algebra.

On a side note, can someone also comment on why we would even care if a transformation is homogeneous vs heterogeneous? In reference to a transformation applied onto a 2D signal (such as an image transformation).

Maybe the better question to ask would be to prove if a transformation is heterogeneous, is it linear? (if so can someone help me define what it means for a transformation to be heterogeneous? Like how a homogeneous transform means T[0] = 0.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ I have a follow up question, according to this link on convolution, convolution has a requirement that the system "must be" linear and time/space invariant. Does this mean we can not use the conventional convolution on a heterogeneous signal, but we can for a homogeneous signal? $\endgroup$ – CLDuser2.- Oct 27 '19 at 21:11
1
$\begingroup$

The idea here is that any Linear Operator is Homogeneous though not every Homogeneous Operator is Linear.

The classic proof indeed is to build the zero term as a sum (Difference) of 2 other elements in the domain. Then use Linearity to show it must be zero:

$$ T \left( 0, 0 \right) = T \left( {m}_{1} - {m}_{1}, {n}_{1} - {n}_{1} \right) = T \left( {m}_{1}, {n}_{1} \right) - T \left( {m}_{1}, {n}_{1} \right) = 0 $$

Maybe the better question to ask would be to prove if a transformation is heterogeneous, is it linear?

As I wrote above, if an operator is heterogeneous is must not be linear.

Think of the simplest Linear Operator in 1D: $ T \left( x \right) = a x $. Clearly it is a linear function and indeed homogeneous.
Let's look on Affine Function: $ T \left( x \right) = a x + b $. Usually this is also called Linear Function while it is not unless $ b = 0 $. Why? It is not heterogeneous.

It is easy to see that $ T \left( {x}_{1} - {x}_{1} \right) \neq T \left( {x}_{1} \right) - T \left( {x}_{1} \right) $.

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.